Everyone Hates McKinsey


The junior employee who says:

“Managers are a complete waste of money - they just sit around doing nothing while others work.”

The first-time founder who says:

“Big-firm lawyers are a total rip-off. I’m paying $700/hour for a contract that should just be a free template.”

The nursing student who says:

“Ugh, doctors don’t know ANYTHING.”

The independent consultant who says:

“Those jerks at McKinsey are a scam. People pay them millions and all they do is create a PowerPoint and walk away.”

Here’s the thing:

This is what I call the Everyone Hates McKinsey Fallacy-

When people at a lower skill level dismiss the value of people at a higher one,

Because they don’t have the perspective to see what is really happening.

And we've all been guilty of it.

I was reminded of this recently talking to a firm that mostly provides bookkeeping and accounting.

When clients occasionally ask about fractional CFO support, they will contract one in

But internally, they usually tell clients, “CFOs don’t really add much value for startups.”

But of course it looks that way to them.

If you're a hard-working bookkeeper with limited exposure to strategic finance education,

A CFO looks like someone just sitting around observing the numbers your produce.

They seem totally unnecessary.

You don't see the nuanced forecasting, the capital raised, the team management, the board alignment, the ROI estimation, or the make-or-break strategy decisions happening behind the curtain.

You don't see that without strategic vision, there's no purpose to those numbers you're tracking.

It is the same everywhere:

  • To a junior employee, managers look like professional calendar blockers
  • To a first-time founder, lawyers look like glorified copy-pasters
  • To a med student, doctors look like people who know theory better than patients
  • And to the outside world, McKinsey looks like a very expensive clip art subscription

But the market is not dumb:

  • Managers exist because decisions are harder than they look
  • Lawyers exist because contracts are landmines.
  • CFOs exist because CEOs know finance is more than counting cash.
  • And McKinsey exists because -slides aside- companies keep paying for billions in value.

The higher the skill, the easier it looks.

The easier it looks, the more likely someone is to assume it does not matter.

Your Daily CFO,

Lauren

Founder-Friendly Finance

CEO-turned-CFO & finance instructor, Lauren Pearl, drops a daily tip that helps startup founders grow their businesses and control their destinies. Learn why this growing list with a 60% open rate led to LP being named top 25 Finance Thought Leader and host of the #3 CFO podcast for 2025

Read more from Founder-Friendly Finance

Recently, I read a comment from a startup advisor peer about the lack of women in VC-funded startup leadership. Essentially: "Maybe this is just a product of preference. Maybe women are just more risk-averse. And maybe men are simply dumb enough to try." While framed as flattery, it disguises something ugly- It’s a tidy explanation for the funding gap That promotes a dangerous narrative Which is also - blatantly - wrong. Women do start venture-backed companies - many of them. About 1 in 5...

AI is supposedly making us faster. In conversations with founders and engineers, I’m hearing the same story: Prototypes that once took weeks now take days. Code that required whole teams now gets drafted in an afternoon. Experiments are cheaper, iteration is faster, and the barrier to entry for creating new products has never been lower. But speed in one part of the system often exposes constraints elsewhere. Recently, I’ve been reading Abundance, Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson’s new book on...

One of the biggest differences when transitioning from doer to manager is how best practices on communication change. When you’re a doer executing for a boss, the best bet is to lead with solutions. Every executer worth their salt eventually realizes that just pointing out problems doesn’t really help the team. That just creates work for someone else (Potentially the exact person deciding whether you stick around to get a raise). So it’s better to carry the ball all the way down the court:...